there was no halcyon past where everyone was reading academic journals and listening to university lectures to figure out the world. the same people who believe in q-anon now believed in john birch society shit 50 years ago and believed in blood libel protocols shit 100 years ago.
People still believe in blood libel protocols shit today, I'm sad to say. Even when the surface elements get modernized, the classics keep right on trucking alongside them.
Yeah, we had plenty of satanic panics and Art Bell and people thinking that natural disasters are God punishing infidels way before social media. People just got them from call-in shows and church groups and tabloids and shit instead
This is so. But those people today are exposed *only* to those things and only in a feedback loop. There is something new and pernicious about it, but I agree it’s not some unified field theory about this moment
the american revolution too. in massachusetts, the patriots believed in a conspiracy that the british were going to convert their province to a crown colony and seize all their weapons (in order to leave them defenseless against the indians), which the british never had any intention of doing
If you ever look at old newspaper clippings, it was literally just the same shit as social media posts. Dumb jokes and whatnot.
I'm always skeptical of people saying that computers ~fundamentally changed human society~ or whatever. It just made it more accessible. It's communication technology.
If anything we're closer to that halcyon vision nowadays than we ever have been, because those things are easily avilable to anyone intrested in looking
Human history is just one long procession of handfuls of exasperated smart people looking at the world around them and saying “Whaaa? I thought we were done with that?” and the masses shouting back “Noooooope!”
one thing I will add is that social media makes these groups easier to access, and makes them harder to escape. if you were some conspiracy crank in the 90s/00s you couldn't easily immerse yourself with people who have the same worldview without doing some pretty deep digging.