I find a hard part of this is convincing progressives that the person who is economically left-leaning but praises Trump/Farage/Le Pen/Modi/Orban/etc. in favour of Liberalism are not being contrarian or rhetorical.
When Musk went after the ADL recently he was just the latest in a long line of far right actors who have tried to pass off their fascistic antisemitism as innocent "free speech" that evil-intended leftist Jews were trying to squelch because they hate freedom. sethcotlar.substack.com/p/the-far-ri...
If there's one meme or talking point that played a central role in the American fascist tradition, it was the claim that "Communism is Jewish." This is how fascist antisemites tried to appear as "normie" anti-communists, by saying they were just pro-Christian. sethcotlar.substack.com/p/antisemiti...
The official 2024 GOP platform makes a reference to "Christian-hating Communists" who the Republicans will keep from entering the country. Back in the early days of the America First movement, "Christian-hating Communists" would have just been a longer way of saying "Jews."
Not enough people understand this. The left doesn't have funding to force an icon. Billionaire RWers do and don't care if they had a few left-wing ideas in the past, so long as they help.
When your schtick is "I'm a leftist who hates Democrats and wants to destroy them," you soon find that the people who want to fund you destroying them are conservatives.
It will get me yelled at to state, but after two plus decades of seeing this trend play out again and again, I simply don’t trust the left not to fall for this over and over again.
Idk, maybe listening to folks who said we shouldn’t support people who defend Assad or dismiss women in pink hats out of hand instead of viciously attacking them as tools of imperialism or centrists is instructive here
Absolutely surreal watching them end American democracy, just six dipshits in a room turning us into a monarchy and legally entrenched oligarchy, incredibly hard to parse this is as reality right now
My Julian Assange story is that we got him to walk back support for Gamergate by threatening to cancel his book launch party, and then after the party he walked back his walk back. I have never forgotten the flexibility of his convictions outside the public eye.
It does not help because it's obvious, there's no one saying otherwise, and you could be making one of a hundred fair points or none at all by emphasizing it
"Reichsbürger übernehmen einen Hof in der Uckermark und Neonazi-Label vertreiben aus ihren Geschäften heraus Hass-Musik und Szenekleidung: Verfassungsschutzbehörden in ganz Ostdeutschland sind alarmiert." #rechtsrocktsnicht
One of my best friends is Jewish, and -- quite rationally -- wary of hard-leftist spaces for reasons such as these.
For me, these people are dire embarrassments. For her, they're dangerous. Just fundamentally unreliable people who can't tell triangulation from reaching fascism by a stack overflow.
there really is a painful cycle of newly politically engaged people getting excited about revolutionary thinking, realizing it doesn’t work like that, and then either becoming cranks or normal liberals. while a lot of the annoying twitter libs were wrong about dirtbag leftists, plenty were right.
I think theres problems with how these people are championed and the values we look for in public voices but i also agree with this. Political celebritydom is a bad bet.
Our only criteria for platforming people is having one or two left wing opinions, hating liberals, being a little savvy with marketing in the age of the internet, and wanting to be famous
There were 16 trans youth suicides after gender affirming care restrictions were implemented in the UK in 2020 compared with only 1 in the 7 years prior. Staff at the NHS attempted to cover it up. Hilary Cass knew but minimized what was happening.
This is a massive scandal. Cass lied, kids died.
some things we, as a society, have recently done to teens:
-traumatized them with gun violence
-vastly reduced their rights to reproductive healthcare
-had a moral panic about their genders
-abandoned them to the ravages of covid, destroying their immune systems
it's not tiktok that fucked em up