there are few things i hate more than the song “try that in a small town.” 1) you call yourself a country musician but you draw the line at “cussing out a cop?” you’re supposed to do coke and write a song about killing a lawman, coward 2) small towns fucking love crime, what are you talking about.
Honestly insulting that they even tried to pull a “noooo, we didn’t mean it like that.” The recent spate of extra-racist country music and musicians is awful but I guess not super surprising.
🤷♂️ It's a fantasy song written by committee & sung by an ambitious dude who went to one of the segregation academies (IYKYK) around Macon GA (which is many things, but not a small town). IMO the song fits that specific background quite well in terms of catering to people's self-delusions.
Also, Jason Aldean is from Macon, GA. And lives in Nashville, TN. I don't think he's ever seen a small town in his life. To me there's few things more pathetic than people like him trying to play the phony country boy schtick
I grew up listening to country music: Hank. Buck. Mother Maybelle. Patsy. George. Loretta. Dolly, before "Jolene" marked her big crossover in 1973 (she was still GREAT after; she just moved in other genres).
Nashville "cowboy pop" isn't country. The idyllic small town it's all set in doesn't exist.
I was recently seated near an older couple at a restaurant who were enjoying the enthusiasm my kids had for their meal, and just being cute in general. I smiled back; shared a knowing look with the dad, etc. And when they left, I saw they had a "Try that in a small town" shirt on and I thought…
There’s another song I can’t stand that’s about “having famous (in a small town) friends” which includes just like. Obvious police corruption and I hate it! I hate it so much!
His fans sure didn't seem to like the cops much when said cops were attempting to evacuate them because there was a tornado warning at the venue down the street from my house last year...they sure love that song but were definitely not living it.
I think Agatha Christie had an observation about small towns: they held the same evil as cities, it's just concentrated.
Definitely not all 'cozy mystery', more like body horror.
It's like how biker clubs are all a bunch of cop glazers now. You peep a row of bikes lined up outside the worst bar in your town and they're all wearing biker cuts with a blue line shield on it.
Country music lost it's way post 9/11 with the hyper patriotism that followed that event. The right used that to completely remove most lefties from mainstream country. Once it got to the point where the Dixie Chicks were run out town for being against the Iraq war, it was done.
it’s so transparently an extremely racist song fantasizing about killing “looters” and communists and it’s so fucking embarrassing. Carrie Underwood wrote like four songs about killing men who wronged her because she isn’t a complete fucking loser
All I could think about was how much fun it would be to run amok in a small southern town. Pushing over old ladies, stealing tractors, running phone scams, defacing public property, etc.
The fact that he specifically says "pull a gun on the owner of a liquor store" as an example of something you can't do in a small town. Small town liquor store clerks live in a state of constant terror that they're going to get shot by a meth head in a robbery gone wrong. And they're right to.
With women the formula is passive + desperate.
Or
Revenge, especially on the judgemental or abusive
And the third sort of song is always like I Hope you Dance or
One way Ticket or are crossover rock songs .
The small town I grew up in had so much crime for only being like ~230 people, half of whom I was related to. There was like a 3 year period where EVERYBODY was having gas siphoned out of their cars in the middle of the night. Also SO much drugs, my one cousin being one of the bigger dealers.
"It is my belief, Watson, founded upon my experience, that the lowest and vilest alleys in London do not present a more dreadful record of sin than does the smiling and beautiful countryside.”
Sherlock Homes, "The Adventure of the Copper Beeches"
Small towns have rampant crime and police corruption under a facade of Americana. I grew up in a small farm town, found out later from a former dealer, there was literally millions of dollars of coke moving through it. The cops would spend their time harassing kids and turning a blind eye to it.
I hate the way that song’s been taken as emblematic of country music and country fans’ attitudes (usually by people who know very little about the genre and accept the easy cliche it serves up).
That’s what you get when country becomes a genre of pop music. Which it mostly did because of 9/11 and the opportunity for grifters to commercialize “patriotism”.