oh hey did y'all know that in 1858 when Charles Dickens was 45 he tried to have his wife institutionalized by falsely claiming she was insane & didn't love the ten children she had borne him, all so he could bang an 18 year old actress in his employ
& this is has only really emerged since 2019
Is there some reference in this to Dickens having an affair with Ellen Ternan?. There is recent work suggesting she was his illegitimate daughter. The evidence is sparse either way. Not to defend Dickens’ attempts to have his wife committed. All to common and evil. Still happens today.
Interesting. Another random fact: Harry Lloyd, the actor who played Viserys Targaryen in Game of Thrones, is the great-great-great grandson of Dickens.
Did you know claiming someone attempted to kill themselves or getting them 5150'd will allow this to be the directive believed before their own words for the rest of their lives? It lingers on police records, hospital records, and causes the "patient" to forfeit their basic civil rights. Protocol.
As Claire Tomalin's 1990 book The Invisible Woman was filmed 2013, and her Dickens biog, which details his treatment of Catherine, was published 2011, it's rather a stretch for the article to claim that 'up to now most accounts of the Dickens marriage break-up have given his side of the story'.
His work is amazing, but yeah. He was every bit the kind of Victorian tool he rages about in his books. I *am* stashing this in my back pocket to taunt my friend who plays Dickens at Dickens Fair with this year though. (I typically play one of the villains half the show, so it’s 100% in character…)
Yowza. In a way I'm glad I missed this discovery in 2019.
During pandemic lockdown I started reading the Dickens I never (had to) read in school, and this might well have thrown me off doing so. Learning of it today makes me hate human complexity/celeb/artist issues anew.
Another subject for the “should we cancel talented monsters” debate.
As it happens I’ve absolutely loathed Dickens and all his mawkish shite ever since having Bleak House inflicted on me in 5th form, so cancel the ever-lasting crap out of him, folks.
So another great writer is revealed to have been a jerk in real life. I once met a writer whose work I admired, and he spent the brief time I talked with him making fun of my disability. His words never spoke the same way to me again, but it filled in some gaps in them, too.
Horrifying, but not exactly surprising. If you want an hour of Sue Perkins dunking on Dickens, please watch Mrs Dickens’ Family Christmas. And yeah, he had real writing chops. It’s so frustrating. youtu.be/dpB-B3Kk4Dw?...
Dumping inconvenient women in asylums was common in Victorian times. LOTS of queer women abused this way. And remember how Freud decided that a girl who reported sexual abuse by her father was actually fanatasizing based on repressed desires? England had a queen but it was misogynist as hell.
"troubled" doing a lot of heavy lifting in the opening passage of that article!
I can still enjoy his works for what they are, nothing to be gained by cancelling a dead guy, I just hope my mother never comes to hear of any of this...
I think he was a legit genius who, like so many, got drunk on fame and money, and believed he was thus justified in getting whatever he wanted. He got more horrible as he went along because Genius.
Power corrupts. But his books are great. (I know, but show me the unproblematic Victorian novels.)
I remember Phyllis Rose mentioning (or implying?) something like this in the 1984 edition of Parallel Lives, based on letters from Catherine's aunt. I'm truly glad it's official now, vs something a lot of scholars dismiss like they did when I was growing up. Thank you for passing it on.
Here’s a classic work about how psychiatry and other social institutions have historically impeded (or attempted to)healthy psychological development in women. Very relevant to this discussion.
So, actually contemporaneous with scandal over (now lesser-known) novelist Edward Bulwer ('dark and stormy night') Lytton having his estranged wife confined in an asylum, en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rosina_... and just before Dickens' actual mate Wilkie Collins published The Woman in White....
He was such a dickhead! He led a full-on character assassination of John Rae when Rae returned to London with evidence that Franklin's crew had turned to cannibalism trying to chart the Northwest Passage (at least partly because he wanted to bang Jane Franklin, imo)
dickens is fascinating because there are these yawning gulfs between his philosophy as expressed in his writing and his interpersonal behavior. dude was regularly writing in the newspaper about how much he hated his fat ugly wife! an unbelievably cruel dude
There's a fairly recent novel called Drood which talks about this all while Dickens is writing Drops and while Wilkie Collins goes slowly insane from opium. I also didn't realize how interesting Dickens daughter Katie was until that
He never was 1 of my favourites:
&,
Did you know that the
Conte of Monte Cristo was a true story, NOT written by Alexander Dumas but PLAGIARISED from old police record written by a legal clerk?
Oh, and isn't this the 18 year old actress to whom the lead female character in A Tale of Two Cities bore a suspiciously close resemblance? My students were SO squicked out when I told them about that.
And Dickens ordered the ten children to never speak to their mother again; all obeyed him except the eldest, a son who basically said “the hell with that” and stuck by his mother and prevented her from becoming destitute.
The original Christmas Carol visitation was the ghost of Old Past Wife, Hot Babysitter Present, and future Unbangable Wife.
God bless us all with hornyness.