I’ve been in a meeting with a number of men (and a handful of women) in suits, and while there has been intelligent discussion, my main impression is that Very Serious People are irrationally complacent about the consequences — economic and political — if Trump wins.
People who don't follow politics closely are often taken in by the "both sides" view that it is all partisan bickering. It's just the polarization and, like weather, it's particularly bad this year. If you tell them one side is driving it, well, you would say that, wouldn't you?
I feel the same about very intelligent friends and coworkers that believe the 2020 election was stolen. They literally deny proof of the deception. "They admitted they lied but you think they didn't?"
They think that since they're part of The Club (where you never face real consequences no matter how bad you are at your job), they'll be able to slide by in a fascist America.
And they have no clue, just like how they have no clue about a lot of things.
Americans who have been here a generation or two have no real concept of what it is like to live in an autocracy/kleptocracy. Those of us who have experienced those feel like we're frantically banging on a window, screaming for them to wake up, but unnoticed by those inside.
There does seem to be a very strong status quo bias to being a VSP, like if you're VS, then you don't think there will be any revolutionary or fundamental change, and as a VSP evidence is irrelevant.
right now Trump's implicit pitch to much of the business community is "if I win I will destroy fed independence and force them to lower interest rates and if Biden wins he will respect it and rates will remain high" and honestly it's not even wrong if all you care about is making money
I blame Nancy Pelosi and I want history to also blame her. She is the person who was in charge of oversight over Trump during his presidency and SHE set the tone of "He's just not worth it" and "There's a school of thought that impeachment could create double jeopardy!" When there is no such thing.
I would suggest ‘rationally complacent.’ Nothing Trump and his minions do will harm them. They will have more money and power. It’s a win win for them. I fear it’s a mistake to underestimate the selfishness, greed, and narcissism at work with these folks.
Chances are it is the result of an intuitive calculation that there will be few consequences they could not themselves circumvent with their assets. As for the basic people and the less than serious people….not their concern.
they can't imagine an America that they're not members of the elite, they don't believe it can happen here. they are dead wrong - everyone has a target on their back in a dictatorship
such types do like the idea of getting rid of functional democracy, but they are stunningly naive and wrong in thinking that the harms they know will happen under a Trumpist regime will only happen to the peasants they don't care about
It's not like they've been hurt by anything the Republicans have done since they pushed the nation rightward and they'll benefit under Trump.
Fact is that the majority of public and private leaders are OK with fascism and an anti-democratic authoritarianism.
Always are.
"Democrats are exaggerating."
"It's just the way Trump campaigns. He doesn't really mean most of that stuff."
"Other people will keep him under control."
But most of all: "It can't happen here."
The time to make these people uncomfortable to their face is now. Dominate and direct the conversation, put your Nobel on the table. I’ve seen this American elite detachment from the outside. We can’t penetrate it. People like you can. If we can assist elite truth-tellers like yourself, let us know.
I wouldn’t be surprised if the complacency doesn’t include a bit of “yes, burn it to the ground. Show the people remaining that it was a mistake.” A very long view, accepting some collapse, a la Hari Seldon.
Any thoughts on why?
Is it that Trump serves their interests?
Is it that they don't believe that the consequences will be what you foresee them to be?
Is it that these Very Serious People are rich enough to afford shielding and options regardless of who is elected president?
A couple of the big US engineering firms seem to be spinning off the bits of their operations that specialise in US Federal work into stand-alone companies. I'd been assuming the timing was just a coincidence, but now you come to mention it maybe they've just thought further ahead.
well yeah, it won't impact them in any real way so why would they care about the rest of us or society
conor friedersdorf is gonna continue to get paid to be tedious either way
very serious people are completely isolated from any personal consequences. it's one of the best reasons to ignore their beliefs. don't ignore their actions which have outsized impact of course.
And they shall all be known as The Van Pappens!
Wait wait, that will never happen here as I’m sure once they’ve got unhindered power Bannon, Miller, Flynn et al with absolutely respect and listen to the delusional fucks who got rich inventing an app.
Very serious people are just crooks in suits. Same as it ever was, watching the real world burn from their posh bubble: They could care less. Brexit and Scamalot Trumpistan were the tells eh?
Maybe tell the newspaper which employs you to wake up, but I'm sure Maggie Haberman will save the day once again with a grift ridden ethics lacking book deal.
The wealthy—and I assume these VSP’s are wealthy—assume that their wealth will always shield them. From crime, from climate, from hunger, from authoritarianism, from everything. Only too late will they realize we’re all in one big sinking ship.
And weirdly, your paper is doing a very good job of obfuscating the threat he poses to the economic and political landscape. Can ya maybe talk to someone about this over there?
They didn’t live through WWII, most of the didn’t live through the Civil Rights Era, and all of them thought history was “boring stuff no one needs to know”
Do you think these Very Serious People are hedging? If Trump wins, we know he'll be a disaster. We also know he'll pick winners & losers.
Biden will play by the rules.
Even though it's unethical, amoral, & short-sited, buttering up TFG is the safer bet if you're motivated by greed.
I’m voting for Biden but the one area his admin has been weak is wealth inequality
Did he really have to bail out billionaire and trillionaire VCs who caused a bank run at SVB only to watch those same VCs now fund Trump?
And the stock market only allowed to go up also induced oligarchy
your board room high off the ground keeps you from seeing brutality inflicted on the streets so you could not imagine the climate event that killed you by downing your helicopter to the Hamptons
The English desease. Politicans, managers and other important people that are strangely distanced from real life and what consequences their decisions can have. Either by upbringing or simply by loads of money. #Eton