Just got a news alert saying Joann Fabrics is going into bankruptcy due to decreasing demand.
Article fails to say that it was purchased by a private equity firm a while ago and recently went public and is carrying $2.4 billion in debt.
Private equity strikes again.
This is a corporate raiders buy a thriving business, strip it for parts, declare bankruptcy and pocket the spoils scenario. Mitt Romney has a lot of experience doing that. I wonder if there are mom and pop stores that can fill the void? Maybe that opportunity could offer some kind of silver lining?
A capitalism story in 4 parts:
1. Private Equity firm buys a niche company a relatively fixed but loyal customer base
2. Lards up company with debt, cuts quality, sales begin to drop
3. PE says "Revenues should be 10x higher than when we bought you!"
4. PE finishes looting the company, liquidates
It’s insane to me that there’s always a bank willing to make these loans that just about every person with a modicum of sense can see is a bad idea. Often made based on slick ad packets about GROWTH that has literally no basis in the market & then they call the lack of this growth decreasing demand.
Well I mean also it sold very overpriced crap quality supplies. If I’m gonna spend $12/yard on fabric, it’s going to be soft (not starchy) cottons with no print errors, no industrial stains, and doesn’t smell funky. eQuilter dot com is FAR SUPERIOR and donates a portion of each purchase to charity.
They did stock buy backs a few years ago and then cut a ton of staff so that most stores are in Dollar Generalesque shape. I would bet craft hobbies are at an all time high.
Jesus! I love Joann Fabrics! I don’t think there is anyone out there who is a duplicate of what they offer - so much variety of crafting supplies.
0 replies
0 reposts
1 likes
Pretty Fly for a Cat Guy (warning: unreliable narrator)@majima.club
[ View ]
I work at JoAnn and I am CONSTANTLY busy, people are buying literal shopping carts full of yarn and fabric, they have a booming cosplay section, and customers constantly tell us how much they prefer shopping at us than the others. I stfg our demand increases monthly.
Who is so foolish as to loan to private equity outfits, since "load up on debt, cash out huge dividends etc, go bankrupt" seems to be the way these outfits make money?
Not too long after my local fabric store closed, too. Luckily we have others, so I don't buy much from Jo-Ann's. My sister briefly worked for them and hated it.
The stores are tragically empty and in disarray, even the locations that used to be the best. Crafts are booming. Huge crochet and macrame and cosplay resurgence and Joann is always low on yarn and novelty fabrics.
It's called a "Bust Out" if you're a monster. It's called a leverage buyout if you're a this side of the legal line scumbag. worldtraining.net/bustout.html
Last time I went to a Joann's, whoever was working there just wasn't around and no customers could get help. We waited about half an hour before leaving. Private equity destroys everything!
The last two decades of “tech” businesses with no actual product and the liquidation of any value and assets for short-term gain has convinced me that there will be no businesses in the next few years. I’m obviously over exaggerating but… am I really?
The store @urbanprole.bsky.social and I go to in order to buy stuff for @nerdykeppie.bsky.social is so packed and understaffed all of the time that we've started buying some of our stuff online instead.
Plus they've switched to these weird name brand fabrics for a bunch of stuff and I'm like...
And they're going to emerge from bankruptcy in about a month, no stores will be closed, no employees will lose their jobs, and God willing the private equity a**holes will be gone.
And they were probably purchased with money at a much lower interest rate than today.
My local Joann's went out of business even after surviving landlord/real-estate-developer games with their building.
(Best replacement I've found so far is Walmart, though Michael's craft stores have some stuff.)
I went to get my semi-annual supply of face wash that is the only thing I found that prevents The Zit from appearing.
"sold The Body Shop to private equity firm Aurelius Group in November"
“Effective today, March 1, 2024, The Body Shop US Limited has ceased operations,”
Goddammit.
I still refuse to buy knitting supplies from the place that buys stolen artifacts from ISIS and won't let its employees get free birth control
... except they weren't "purchased by a private equity firm", the terms of their reorganization require them to undo their public offering, and it's "only" 1.2billion in debt, not 2.4. They over expanded due to their covid bump, and are paying for it now.
Joann’s was the last surviving chain at which to buy fabric and other sewing supplies.
Plenty of people are still sewing. Alterations are still a thing. And creating a dress or jacket of your own is a joy. I would not ever buy fabric online: texture, weight, drape are impossible to judge.
An acquaintance & I went to the local JoAnn Fabrics store just this weekend and both of us were saying to each other, "We have to stay strong and not blow hundreds of dollars on yarn/fabric we don't need."
"Decreasing demand" my ass. Private equity is a bloated tick that sucks dry good businesses.
Bummer. I preferred Hancock's, and even more so some non-franchise stores that have gone out of business, but we've been buying from them for years. Thanks for the info.
I want the articles that say "Here's what PE psid to buy it, here's the debt they added, here's how much PE extracted in dividends and interest and service fees. And here are the layoffs. And now here the bankruptcy financials..."
I want that for every PE bankruptcy filing story, front and center.
It’s disturbing that all their targets seem to be creative outlets, whether as finished goods like blogs and websites or as raw materials suppliers. What a gray and boring world they want to leave us.
Reminds me of my childhood with Mitt Romney and Bain Capital taking over KB Toys and driving it into the ground because it was more profitable than letting it exist.
If they close stores, then it will leave Michael's (which really doesn't do fabrics) and Hobby Lobby (which I avoid, and which has only a small fabric section that I remember) as sources for fabrics, outside of boutique quilting and haberdashery supply stores.
Where to get basic-but-pretty cottons?